-
» Excellent «
This publication "Psychology and White-Collar Crime - Compliance Recommendations Based on the Social and Psychological Reality Dictating Perception" by Fabian Maximilian Johannes Teichmann and Chiara Wittmann delves into the psychological and social dynamics influencing compliance and non-compliance, particularly in white collar crime. It provides insights into the motivations behind non-compliance and offers practical recommendations for constructing effective compliance programs, focusing on the role of social behavior and perceptions of authority. These insights are important for legal professionals aiming to mitigate white collar crime through robust compliance programs.
Starting with Social Proof Theory, which involves individuals mimic behavior of others when faced with uncertainty, relying on social cues to guide their actions. In legal contexts, this means that employees may follow the lead of their peers regarding compliance, particularly in ambiguous situations. This social component is critical in shaping ethical decision-making within organizations. Another factor is that ethical decision making is deeply embedded in social contexts, influenced by relationships with colleagues, personal economic conditions, and overall workplace culture. Compliance decisions are often the result of a complex interplay of these social factors, making it essential to consider the broader social environment when addressing non-compliance. People also tend to conform to the behavior patterns of their social groups. This phenomenon can lead to either widespread compliance or non-compliance depending on the prevailing norms within the group. Establishing a culture of integrity within an organization can foster a group identity that supports compliant behavior.
Compliance is significantly influenced by how authority figures are perceived. Employees are more likely to follow rules and regulations if they view the enforcing authority as legitimate and fair. This perception of legitimacy is crucial for the effective implementation of compliance programs. Legitimacy is a psychological attribute that individuals ascribe to authority figures whom they believe are rightful and just. For compliance programs to succeed, it is essential that the authority enforcing them is perceived as legitimate. This involves fair and transparent enforcement of rules. The author also shares the following practical recommendations for compliance programs:
Cultural Interpretation: Compliance programs must be sensitive to cultural differences, especially for multinational corporations. Misunderstandings due to cultural discrepancies can lead to non-compliance. Promoting a universal culture of integrity that emphasizes core values can help mitigate these issues.
Influencing Perceptions: Subtle priming techniques and the strategic use of stimuli can influence behavior towards compliance. However, it is crucial to ensure transparency and provide complete information to prevent manipulation and foster genuine compliance.
Creating a Compliance-Conducive Environment: An environment that promotes compliance is essential. This involves establishing and maintaining normative standards that reflect the organization’s values, thereby encouraging employees to internalize these standards and act accordingly.
Addressing Cognitive Heuristics: Decision-making often relies on cognitive shortcuts or heuristics. Providing clear, accurate, and comprehensive information can help employees make informed decisions, thereby reducing reliance on potentially misleading heuristics.
The costs for not staying within the guidelines of compliance can lead to significant legal and financial repercussions, including fines, legal actions, and loss of reputation. The 2008 Global Financial Crisis exemplifies the severe consequences of systemic non-compliance and inadequate regulation. Even though investing in compliance programs, can be resource-intensive, it offers long-term benefits by preventing legal issues, enhancing productivity, and promoting stability. Effective compliance programs can provide a competitive advantage and safeguard against regulatory breaches.
You can find more on this topic here: Fabian Teichmann, Chiara Wittmann (2022). https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JFC-07-2022-0158/full/html